References: Who to Choose and How to List Them
Master the art of professional references: learn who to choose, when to list them, what information to provide, how to prep your references, and what to do about bad references.
Introduction
"Can we contact your references?"
This question means you're close. Very close. You've impressed on paper, survived the interviews, and now they want to verify what you've told them.
Yet most job seekers treat references as an afterthought—scrambling at the last minute, choosing poorly, failing to prepare their references, or worse, listing people who will give lukewarm (or negative) feedback.
Hiring manager Karen Williams shares: "I've had candidates lose offers because of poor references. Not because of outright negative comments, but because the reference seemed unenthusiastic, couldn't remember specific projects, or contradicted what the candidate told us. Strong references confirm the hire decision. Weak ones create doubt."
This guide will teach you exactly how to select strong references, prepare them properly, handle reference checks strategically, and deal with challenging reference situations.
When to Include References on Your Resume vs. Separate Sheet
On Your Resume: Rarely
Don't include references on your resume unless:
The job posting specifically requests them
- "Please include references on your resume"
- Follow instructions exactly
You're in certain industries (academia, government, some international positions)
- Check industry norms
You have extremely impressive references (rare)
- Former CEO, industry luminary, someone recognizable
- Even then, consider a separate sheet
Why not on your resume?
- Takes valuable space that could showcase achievements
- References don't influence early screening decisions
- Privacy concerns (your references' contact info circulating)
- References are checked late in the process, not during initial review
Separate Reference Sheet: Standard Approach
Create a separate document that:
- Matches your resume header/formatting
- Lists 3-5 professional references
- Provides name, title, company, relationship, contact information
- Is ready to send when requested
When to provide it:
- When specifically requested (usually after interviews)
- When filling out application that has a references section
- When you reach finalist stage
Sample reference sheet:
JOHN SMITH
Senior Marketing Manager
john.smith@email.com | (555) 123-4567
PROFESSIONAL REFERENCES
SARAH JOHNSON
Director of Marketing, TechCorp
Former Manager (supervised me for 3 years at TechCorp)
Email: sarah.johnson@techcorp.com
Phone: (555) 234-5678
MICHAEL CHEN
VP of Sales, StartupCo
Internal Client/Cross-Functional Partner (collaborated on 10+ campaigns)
Email: michael.chen@startupco.com
Phone: (555) 345-6789
EMILY RODRIGUEZ
Senior Marketing Manager, Adobe
Former Peer/Colleague (worked together for 2 years)
Email: emily.rodriguez@adobe.com
Phone: (555) 456-7890
"References Available Upon Request": Outdated?
The Traditional Line
"References available upon request"
This phrase appeared at the bottom of nearly every resume for decades.
Current Best Practice: Omit It
Why it's outdated:
It's assumed – Of course you'll provide references if asked. You don't need to state it.
Wastes space – Even one line is valuable real estate on a resume.
Doesn't add value – It doesn't make you more likely to get an interview.
Sounds formal and dated – Modern resumes are achievement-focused, not formality-focused.
When to Still Use It
Very limited situations:
- Your industry still uses it (check 10+ resume examples from your field)
- You need to fill a small amount of space on page 2 (though adding another achievement is better)
- International applications where it's expected
Better alternatives:
- Remove it and add another achievement bullet
- Remove it and improve white space/readability
- Remove it and extend an existing section
What to Do Instead
Have your reference sheet ready:
- Prepare a separate reference document
- Update it every 6-12 months
- Keep it in the same folder as your resume
- Send it promptly when requested
Choosing the Right References
The Ideal Reference Mix: 3-5 People
Standard mix for most candidates:
Recent manager(s) (1-2 people)
- Most important reference type
- Can speak to your performance, work quality, and growth
- Ideally your most recent manager
Senior colleague or client (1 person)
- Can speak to collaboration, expertise, and impact
- Adds different perspective than direct manager
Direct report or peer (1 person – optional)
- Shows leadership and teamwork from different angle
- Particularly valuable for management roles
Professor or academic advisor (for recent graduates)
- Acceptable if you have limited work experience
- Should speak to skills relevant to target role
Reference Type 1: Managers/Supervisors
Why they're critical:
- Hiring managers weigh supervisor references most heavily
- Can speak to your day-to-day performance
- Know your strengths, areas for development, and growth
- Can verify your accomplishments
Best choices:
- Your most recent manager (if you left on good terms)
- Manager from 1-2 roles ago (if current relationship is strong)
- Skip level manager if you had meaningful interaction
Red flags if you can't provide: If you can't list your most recent manager, be prepared to explain why in interviews.
Acceptable explanations:
- "I'm currently employed and conducting a confidential search"
- "My manager was laid off and I've lost contact" (try to reconnect)
- "I had a personality conflict, but I can provide my manager's manager"
Not acceptable:
- Refusing to provide any supervisors
- Only listing references from 10+ years ago
- Providing all peer references when you've had multiple managers
Reference Type 2: Colleagues and Peers
Who qualifies:
- Colleagues at your level
- Cross-functional partners (sales + marketing, engineering + product)
- People you collaborated with on significant projects
What they can speak to:
- Collaboration and teamwork skills
- Technical expertise (peer perspective)
- Problem-solving abilities
- Communication and interpersonal skills
Best choices:
- Senior colleagues (more credibility than junior peers)
- People from different departments (shows cross-functional skills)
- Colleagues from impressive companies or roles
When peer references are especially valuable:
- Management roles (shows you can work with peers, not just lead down)
- Cross-functional roles (product manager, project manager)
- Team-based work environments
Reference Type 3: Direct Reports
Who qualifies:
- People who reported to you directly
- Team members you mentored
- Interns or junior employees you supervised
What they can speak to:
- Leadership style
- Mentorship and development capabilities
- Management effectiveness
- How you handle challenges and pressure
When to include:
- You're applying for management or leadership roles
- The job posting emphasizes people development
- You want to demonstrate upward, peer, and downward relationship success
Best practices:
- Choose direct reports who've grown under your leadership (promoted, developed new skills)
- Ensure they can articulate specific examples of your leadership
- Don't make all 3-5 references direct reports (mix is better)
Reference Type 4: Clients and Customers
Who qualifies:
- External clients you've served
- Internal stakeholders you've supported
- Partners or vendors you've worked with
What they can speak to:
- Client service and relationship management
- Results delivered
- Communication and responsiveness
- Strategic thinking and problem-solving
When to include:
- Client-facing roles (account management, consulting, customer success)
- You delivered exceptional results for a well-known client
- You're transitioning from vendor/consultant to employee
Best practices:
- Choose clients where you drove measurable results
- Ensure they're professional and articulate
- Brief them on what aspects of your work to emphasize
Reference Type 5: Professors and Academic Advisors
Who qualifies:
- Professors from recent degree program
- Academic advisors or thesis supervisors
- Faculty members from relevant coursework
When to use:
- Recent graduates (within 1-2 years)
- Career changers who completed recent degree/program
- You have limited professional work experience
What they can speak to:
- Academic performance and intellectual capability
- Work ethic and reliability
- Research skills or technical knowledge
- Communication and collaboration (from group projects)
When NOT to use:
- You have 5+ years of professional experience (professional references are expected)
- The professor doesn't remember you well
- You can provide 3+ strong professional references
Who NOT to Choose
❌ Family members (never acceptable) ❌ Close personal friends (unless they're also professional colleagues) ❌ People who will give mediocre references ("they were fine" is damaging) ❌ References from 15+ years ago (unless you have ongoing relationship) ❌ People who don't know your recent work ❌ Anyone you haven't spoken to in 5+ years (reconnect first) ❌ References who are poor communicators (even if they like you) ❌ People at companies you left on bad terms (even if that individual liked you)
How Many References to Prepare: 3-5 Ideal
The Standard: 3 References
Most job applications request 3 references.
This typically includes:
- 2 managers/supervisors
- 1 peer, client, or direct report
OR
- 1 manager/supervisor
- 1 senior colleague or client
- 1 peer or direct report
The Recommended: 5 References Ready
Why prepare more than you'll submit?
Availability – Your first choice might be on vacation, changed jobs, or unavailable
Customization – Different references for different roles
- Client reference for client-facing role
- Technical peer for technical role
- Direct report reference for management role
Reference fatigue – If you're interviewing at 5 companies, you don't want to burden the same 3 people repeatedly
Backup options – If one reference doesn't respond or gives weaker feedback than expected
How to Organize Your Reference List
Create a reference tracking spreadsheet:
| Name | Title | Relationship | Company | Phone | Last Used | Notes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sarah Johnson | VP Marketing | Former Manager | TechCorp | sarah@email.com | 555-1234 | 3/15/24 | Strong advocate, prepped for leadership roles |
| Mike Chen | Director Sales | Cross-functional partner | StartupCo | mike@email.com | 555-2345 | 1/10/24 | Can speak to collaboration, client work |
Track:
- When you last used each reference
- Which roles you've used them for
- Their specific strengths (what they speak to best)
- Preparation status (have you briefed them recently?)
Asking Permission and Prepping References
Step 1: Always Ask Permission First
Never list someone as a reference without asking.
Why this matters:
- It's professional courtesy
- They might be unavailable or uncomfortable
- You need to prepare them properly
- Surprise reference calls lead to weak responses
How to Ask for Permission
Email template:
Subject: Reference Request for [Job Title] Applications
Hi [Name],
I hope you're doing well! I'm currently exploring new opportunities in [field/industry], and I'm specifically targeting [type of role, e.g., "senior marketing positions at tech companies"].
Given our time working together at [Company] on [specific projects/time period], I was hoping you'd be willing to serve as a professional reference for me. I believe you can speak well to my [specific skills, e.g., "project management skills and cross-functional collaboration"].
If you're comfortable being a reference, I'll send you more details when I'm in the final stages with companies. Of course, I'll always give you a heads-up before anyone reaches out.
Please let me know if this works for you. I really appreciate your support!
Best,
[Your Name]
Phone call approach (for close relationships):
"Hi Sarah, I wanted to reach out because I'm starting to look for new opportunities. Given how well we worked together at TechCorp, would you be comfortable serving as a reference for me? I'd really value your perspective on my work."
Step 2: Prepare Your References
When to prepare them:
- When they agree to be a reference (high-level prep)
- When you're in final rounds with a specific company (detailed prep)
- Before providing their contact information
What to provide:
Email template for specific opportunity:
Subject: Heads Up: Reference Call Coming for [Company Name]
Hi [Name],
Quick heads up—I'm in the final stages with [Company Name] for a [Job Title] position, and they'll likely be reaching out to you as a reference in the next few days.
Here's some helpful context:
Role: [Job Title] at [Company]
Key Responsibilities: [Brief description, 1-2 sentences]
What They're Looking For: [Top 2-3 skills/qualities from job description]
It would be great if you could speak to:
• [Specific skill or project, e.g., "My project management skills, especially the Product Launch project we worked on together"]
• [Another skill, e.g., "My ability to collaborate across teams"]
• [Another skill, e.g., "How I handled the Q3 crisis situation"]
I've attached my resume for reference, and here are a few talking points that might be helpful:
• [Achievement from your time working together]
• [Another achievement]
• [Strength they observed in you]
Please let me know if you have any questions! I really appreciate your support.
Best,
[Your Name]
Key elements:
- Job title and company
- What skills they should emphasize
- Specific projects or examples they can mention
- Your resume for their reference
Step 3: Provide Talking Points
Make it easy for your references to rave about you:
Sample talking points document:
REFERENCE TALKING POINTS FOR [YOUR NAME]
Our Working Relationship:
• Worked together at TechCorp from 2020-2023
• You were my manager for 3 years
• I reported directly to you on the Marketing team
Key Projects We Collaborated On:
1. Product Launch Campaign (Q2 2022) – Generated $2M in first-year revenue
2. Website Redesign (2021) – Increased conversion rate by 40%
3. Marketing Automation Implementation – Reduced manual work by 20 hours/week
Strengths You Observed:
• Project management and ability to juggle multiple priorities
• Data-driven decision making
• Collaboration with cross-functional teams (Sales, Product, Engineering)
• Taking initiative and ownership
Growth During Our Time Working Together:
• Promoted from Marketing Specialist to Senior Marketing Specialist
• Took on team leadership responsibilities
• Developed expertise in marketing automation and analytics
Feel free to share any of these examples, or others that come to mind!
Common Reference Check Questions
Prepare your references for these standard questions:
"How do you know [Candidate]?"
- Relationship, time period, context
"What were their main responsibilities?"
- Your role, scope, key projects
"What are their greatest strengths?"
- 2-3 specific strengths with examples
"What are areas where they could improve?"
- Prepare them to give a "weakness that's actually a strength" (e.g., "Sometimes too detail-oriented" or "Can take on too much")
"Can you give an example of a challenging situation and how they handled it?"
- Provide 1-2 specific stories they can reference
"How did they handle feedback or criticism?"
- Examples of times you incorporated feedback
"Would you rehire them?"
- Ideally: "Absolutely, without hesitation"
"On a scale of 1-10, how would you rate their performance?"
- Prepare them to say 8-10 (anything below 8 raises concerns)
"Why did they leave your organization?"
- Ensure your story matches what they'll say
"Is there anything else we should know?"
- Opportunity for them to emphasize a key strength
What Information to Provide
On Your Reference Sheet
For each reference, include:
Full Name
- Professional name as they'd introduce themselves
Current Job Title
- "Director of Marketing" not "Marketing Director"
- Update regularly (people change jobs!)
Current Company
- Where they work now, not where you worked together (unless same)
Relationship to You
- "Former Manager at TechCorp (2020-2023)"
- "Cross-functional colleague at StartupCo"
- "Client at Adobe (managed account 2021-2023)"
Email Address
- Professional email they check regularly
- Confirm it's current
Phone Number
- Cell phone (more reliable than office)
- Include area code
Best Time to Reach (Optional)
- "Available M-F, 9am-5pm PT"
- Helpful for busy executives
Sample Reference Sheet Format
JENNIFER MARTINEZ
Senior Product Manager
jennifer.martinez@email.com | (650) 555-7890 | San Francisco, CA
LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/jennifermartinez
PROFESSIONAL REFERENCES
1. DAVID THOMPSON
Vice President of Product
Google
Former Manager at TechStart (supervised me for 4 years, 2019-2023)
Email: david.thompson@google.com
Phone: (650) 555-1111
Available: M-F, 9am-6pm PT
2. SARAH CHEN
Director of Engineering
Meta
Cross-Functional Partner at TechStart (collaborated 2020-2023)
Email: sarah.chen@meta.com
Phone: (415) 555-2222
3. MICHAEL RODRIGUEZ
Senior Product Manager
Amazon
Former Peer/Colleague at TechStart (worked together 2019-2023)
Email: michael.rodriguez@amazon.com
Phone: (206) 555-3333
4. EMILY WONG
Product Manager
Stripe
Former Direct Report at TechStart (mentored 2021-2023)
Email: emily.wong@stripe.com
Phone: (415) 555-4444
All references have been notified and are prepared to speak about my work.
Handling Bad References
Identifying Potential Problem References
Warning signs:
- You left the company on bad terms
- You were fired or performance-managed
- Your manager seemed dissatisfied with your work
- You had interpersonal conflicts
- You suspect someone would give negative feedback
Strategy 1: Don't List Them
If possible, work around problem references:
- List your manager's manager (if you had good relationship)
- List manager from previous role
- List strong peer or client references
- Be prepared to explain the gap if asked
Strategy 2: Address It Proactively
If you must list them or know they'll be contacted:
In the interview:
"I want to be transparent: my last manager and I had different working styles, and I don't believe I'll receive the strongest reference from them. However, my manager before that and my cross-functional partners can speak highly to my work quality and collaboration. I've learned a lot from that experience about communication and cultural fit."
Why this works:
- Shows self-awareness
- Demonstrates honesty
- Frames it as learning experience
- Directs attention to stronger references
Strategy 3: Reach Out to Potentially Negative Reference
Sometimes, a direct conversation helps:
Email template:
Subject: Reference Request
Hi [Name],
I'm currently in the interview process for a [Job Title] role, and I wanted to reach out because I know we had some challenges during my time at [Company].
I've done a lot of reflection since then and have grown significantly in [areas where there were issues, e.g., "time management and communication"]. I'm hoping we can put our past working relationship in context, and I'd appreciate it if you could speak to my strengths in [specific areas where you did well].
I understand if you're not comfortable serving as a reference, and I respect that. Please let me know.
Best,
[Your Name]
Possible outcomes:
- They decline (gives you a heads up to work around them)
- They agree but will be lukewarm (you know what to expect)
- They're more positive than you expected (pleasant surprise)
Strategy 4: Provide Additional Strong References
If you have one weak reference:
- Provide 4-5 references instead of 3
- Make sure the others are exceptionally strong
- The positive references can outweigh one lukewarm one
What Companies Can Legally Ask
Varies by jurisdiction, but generally:
Allowed:
- Job title and employment dates
- Job responsibilities
- Performance and work quality
- Reason for leaving (if truthful)
- Eligibility for rehire
Often Avoided (legal risk for reference):
- Salary information (banned in some states)
- Personal information (age, marital status, etc.)
- Unverified claims or opinions stated as facts
Many companies have policies limiting references to:
- "Name, dates of employment, and job title only" (especially HR departments)
- This is why direct manager references are valuable—they often speak more freely
Professional Reference Services
When to consider:
- You have limited professional references
- You're early in your career
- You've had multiple short-term positions
- You're concerned about reference quality
What they provide:
- Professional references from your instructors/mentors in their program
- Skills verification
- Work sample validation
Reputable services:
- Bootcamp instructors (coding bootcamps, etc.)
- Professional development program leaders
- Volunteer organization supervisors
- Freelance clients (if formalized)
Note: These are supplements, not replacements for traditional professional references. Hiring managers still prefer references from actual work contexts.
Following Up After Reference Checks
Thank Your References
Always send thank you notes after references are contacted:
Email template:
Subject: Thank You!
Hi [Name],
I wanted to thank you for serving as a reference for my application to [Company]. They completed reference checks this week, and I really appreciate you taking the time to speak with them.
[If you got the job:]
I'm excited to share that I accepted the offer! I start on [date] as [Job Title]. Thank you for being part of making this happen.
[If you didn't get the job:]
Unfortunately, they decided to go with another candidate, but I'm grateful for your support throughout my search.
I really value our professional relationship and hope to stay in touch. Please let me know if I can ever return the favor!
Best,
[Your Name]
Keep References Updated
Maintain relationships:
- Connect on LinkedIn
- Send occasional updates (new role, major achievement)
- Offer to serve as their reference if needed
- Meet for coffee/lunch periodically
Update your reference list regularly:
- Every 6-12 months, review and update
- Confirm contact information is current
- Add new strong references as you develop relationships
- Remove references from too long ago
Action Plan
This Week:
Identify 5-7 potential references
- 2-3 managers
- 2-3 peers/colleagues
- 1-2 clients or direct reports
Reach out to ask permission
- Use email template provided
- Get confirmation from at least 3-5 people
Create your reference tracking spreadsheet
- Name, title, company, relationship, contact info
This Month:
Prepare high-level talking points
- Key projects you worked on together
- Strengths they can speak to
- Your resume for their reference
Create formatted reference sheet
- Match your resume header
- Include all required information
- Save as PDF
Test your references
- If possible, have a trusted friend call for a "reference check"
- Identify which references are strongest
Ongoing:
Keep references warm
- Update them every few months
- Let them know when you accept a new role
- Thank them sincerely
Update your reference list
- As you change jobs, add new strong references
- Keep contact information current
- Refresh talking points regularly
Conclusion
References are your final hurdle before the offer.
You've impressed on paper. You've succeeded in interviews. Now your references need to seal the deal.
The difference between:
Weak reference: "Yeah, they worked here. They were fine. I don't remember specific projects. They did their job."
and
Strong reference: "Absolutely, I'd rehire them in a heartbeat. Let me tell you about the Q3 product launch where they exceeded every target and solved a major technical challenge. I actually tried to convince them to stay when they left."
...is often the difference between "We're going with another candidate" and "We'd like to extend you an offer."
Don't leave this to chance.
Choose your references strategically. Ask permission. Prepare them thoroughly. Make it easy for them to advocate for you powerfully.
Your references are the final voices hiring managers hear before making their decision.
Make sure those voices are saying exactly what you need them to say.